About Mystery Tackle Box

Mystery Tackle Box is a new subscription service that describes itself as “a fun way to discover baits” with their monthly box filled with items that are trusted by fishing professionals.  

How Does It Work?

After members sign up for a specific subscription plan type, they will be asked what type of fish species you normally fish for. Currently this company offers boxes for bass fishing, including largemouth, smallmouth, and spotted, as well as inshore saltwater fishing, like redfish, drum, snook, and stripers. 

They also currently offer boxes for panfishing, crappie, perch, bluegills, as well as seasonal ice fishing boxes, and if you don’t see your preference listed, the company asks that you check back periodically as they are always adding more species. Customers are also welcome to change their type of box, or add a second species box. 

The products included in their box are intended for both beginners and experts, and each box will include an “About Your Box” card that explains all the bait you have received in your box, as well as links for their website to videos, product reviews, learning rigging options, and much more. 

The website says that most anglers will spend $25 to $50 per month on fishing gear, and their box provides equipment valued in that price range at a much more affordable option. 

Cost/Price Plans

There are four different billing packages that customers can choose from. The first is their Month-to-Month option, which will cost $15.00 per month and is billed monthly. Customers can also choose to be billed quarterly, which will result in $14.50 per month, or $43.50 billed every 90 days. 

The website says their most popular option is the bi-annual option, which costs $14.25 per month, or $85.50 billed every six months, and finally they also offer a yearly subscription, which costs $13.75 per month and is billed annually at $165.00. Shipping is always free.

Refund Policy

Mystery Tackle Box does not provide a standard Refund Policy that is applicable to all situations. Instead, they claim that all products which are shipped from their facility have been inspected for quality before they are ever boxed. When you become a Mystery Tackle Box customer, you acknowledge that you will be surprised by the products that are provided to you. Unfortunately this means that this company does not offer refunds for products. 

In addition, customers who cancel their subscription before the end of their subscription term will not receive a refund either – they will simply continue receiving their boxes until the end of their agreed term, and then their subscription will stop. 

Customer Service Contact Info

Customers who would like to speak to their Customer Service team about their questions, concerns, or complaints can do so by email at [email protected] 


The Mystery Tackle Box website provides a list of links that go to fishing websites, YouTube videos, and websites of professional anglers, all of which are intended to show customers positive reviews from people they should trust.

In addition, a review of blogs that cover monthly subscription boxes shows that this company and service has many positive reviews and it appears that many of their customers are satisfied not only with their service and their products, but also with the monthly costs of this service.   

Competitors and Alternatives?

There are many other monthly subscription services available for people who are interested in beauty or grooming products, or gourmet food products, but Mystery Tackle Box and their competitor TackleGrab.com seem unique in their focus on fishing products.   

If you have experience with this company or their products, please leave your Mystery Tackle Box reviews below.

Related Articles

0 ‘Mystery Tackle Box’ Reviews

Leave a Review